Sharon Astyk: Home Economics, Sustainability and the "Mommy Wars"

I've heard a great many bloggers refer warmly to Sharon Astyk's work, but I had only dropped by her site briefly here and there. As we are soon expecting the birth of our baby boy, one of her recent posts (via Energy Bulletin) really struck me as incredibly insightful and well-conceived. She really hits on some major points on the structure of our society and its effects on the happiness of both parents and children. An excerpt:

Until 200 years ago, a vast majority of all children spent most of their lives with both parents every single day. In hunter-gatherer societies, the tribe often travelled together, and since hunting was generally a less common activity than gathering, male hunters often had considerable time to spend with their children. In most such societies in existence today, they do a considerable amount of parenting. Once agriculture came to predominate, again, children spent their days with their parents. Young, nursing children were often with their mother, but by the age of weaning (four or five in most traditional societies, unless a younger sibling pushed it ahead), children might work or play alongside their fathers for part of every day. Boys would join their fathers in traditionally male work, but even daughters would often help in the barn or around the farm. Everyone would recovene for regular meals, and the family would spend all sabbaths and festivals together. Many agricultural societies had much more free time than we do now - 11th century serfs worked only 178 days per year. Helena Norberg-Hodge has documented that the people of Ladakh, one of the harshest climates in the world, were able to feed themselves by working intensely only four months of the year, spending much of the winter in celebration and parties, and described the integration of children into the lives of both parents and grandparents as well.

It’s nice to see more

It’s nice to see more people speaking out about this. A few years ago I came to my own conclusion that if you fix all the families, you'll fix 90% of the world’s problems. Sharon couldn’t have written a more insightful article on the topic. Cohousing helps dramatically with feelings of isolation, which is common with today’s SAHM.

Cohousing

I've been wondering about the legal ramifications of trying to form a self-sufficient community. The fact that statutes on co-housing exist is encouraging, and the thought of using condo rules hadn't occurred to me. Very good info.

This reminds me of the PBS

This reminds me of the PBS series from a few years back -- a "reality" show about going back to prairie pioneering days. When it was over, it seemed most of the participants agreed that it was a lot of hard work, but it was REWARDING work. Mind you, none of them made the ultimate cut -- none of them would have survived the upcoming winter.

The personal independence we have fought to win over the last century or so -- fragmenting ourselves into "nuclear families" -- has come with a high price tag. Children have lost opportunities to learn from elders, sometimes even from their own parents. With escalating health care costs, I truly believe we will once again return to the days when adults house not just their children, but also their own parents. But I don't see that as bad, so long as it is foreseen and planned for.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.